November 18, 2026 · 6 min read

Ask Fall Closings for Reviews Before Year End: A November Review Plan

Clients who closed this fall are willing to speak well of you right now. Here is the ask by text, email and closing gift, where each review goes, how to reply, and a two week schedule.

Ask Fall Closings for Reviews Before Year End: A November Review Plan

Ask every client who closed this fall for one review, in the same words, on one Google profile, after a thank-you note and never with a gift attached to the request. Send it by text if you text them, by email if you do not, and reply to each review within two days.

That is the whole plan. It follows the review request script we set up as part of our Google Business Profile work, and you can run it without us.

November is the last quiet stretch before the holidays. A client who closed six weeks ago remembers who answered the phone at 9 PM. One who closed in March needs a reminder.

Why the fall closings are your best list

NAR's 2025 Profile of Home Buyers and Sellers reports that 91 percent of buyers would use their agent again or recommend them, with 76 percent saying they definitely would. The same profile found that 62 percent of buyers who purchased within the last year had already recommended their agent, and that 65 percent of sellers had recommended their agent at least once since selling their home in the last year.

People tell friends within months, out loud. A review is the same sentence written where a stranger can find it.

Past clients also carry more of the business each year. NAR REALTOR News, reporting on the 2026 Member Profile, says the typical NAR member earned 28% of their business from past clients and customers, up from 20% last year.

These figures do not say a review causes a referral. They say the willingness is there.

Choose the profile before you write the message

"Leave us a review online" makes the client decide where, which usually means they do not. Pick one destination and send one link. For most teams that is the Google Business Profile for the office or team, because strangers see it when they search your name. Google's help page for managing reviews says you can ask customers to visit a Google link or scan a QR code, and that customers must be signed into a Google Account to leave a review.

Use this order for which profile gets the review:

  1. The team or office profile, if the client worked with a team that has its own listing on Google Maps.

  2. The agent's own profile, if the agent runs a solo business with a profile of their own.

Put the choice on a list, one line per past client: name, closing date, profile link.

The ask, word for word, by channel

Name a real moment, make one request, keep it short. The examples use a made-up buyer.

Text message

"Hi Dana, it's Marcus. I was thinking about the day you got the keys and the dog ran straight to the back door. Thank you for trusting me with it. If you have two minutes and a Google account, a short review of how the process went would help other people find us. Here is the link: [link]. No pressure, and thank you either way."

Email

Subject: Two minutes, if you are willing

"Hi Dana, thank you again for letting me help with your move. Your honest words help the next person decide. If you are willing, this link opens a short review form: [link]. It needs a Google sign-in, and you can write as much or as little as you like. Warmly, Marcus."

At the closing gift

The gift is a thank-you, and the ask is separate. Hand it over with a handwritten note that says thank you and nothing more. Put a small card in the bag with a QR code and one line: "If you ever want to share how it went, this opens our Google page." If you mention it aloud, say it once, tell them to do it later, and do not wait while they pull out a phone.

Keep the ask clean

The rules matter more than the wording. The same help page says that offering incentives, like free or discounted goods or services, in exchange for posting reviews is considered fake and misleading content and is strictly prohibited. That rules out a gift card, a raffle entry, a discount, or a closing gift that depends on a review.

Google's Maps user contributed content policy adds two limits. Businesses may not discourage or prohibit negative reviews, or selectively solicit positive reviews. They should also not pressure people to write reviews while on the premises.

Turn those rules into three habits:

  • Build the list by closing date, not by mood. Everyone who closed between September 1 and November 15 gets the same message.

  • Never ask for a rating. "A review" is fine. "A five-star review" is not.

  • Never send a link that sorts people. Routing only happy clients to Google is the selective solicitation the policy rules out.

Reply to every review

Google's help page says it is best practice to reply to reviews and share your perspective. For negative reviews it advises responding in a timely manner and personalizing the reply. Two templates cover most cases.

The warm review. "Thank you, Dana. The inspection week was the hard part, and you handled it with patience. Enjoy the house. Marcus."

The critical review. Use the name, state one fact about what you will change, and invite the conversation offline: "Dana, I am sorry the closing date moved twice. I have called to talk it through, and we will add a written timeline to the way we run closings. Thank you for telling us." Do not argue or ask for removal. Our post on what one bad Google review can cost you goes deeper on that case.

The two week schedule

One person owns this, usually the transaction coordinator or marketing lead. Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, November 26, so keep that day and the next quiet.

  1. Days 1 and 2. Build the list: every closing since September 1, with the profile link on each line.

  2. Day 3. Each agent writes two sentences for each client, one real moment from the transaction. The coordinator pastes them into the template.

  3. Days 4 and 5. Send the first batch, about half the list.

  4. Days 6 to 8. Reply to every review that has landed. Thank anyone who answered but did not review.

  5. Days 9 and 10. Send the second batch to the rest.

  6. Days 11 to 13. Keep replying. Share the best review in a post, with the client's permission.

  7. Day 14. Send one follow-up to anyone who has not responded: "Just in case it got buried, here is the link. No worries if not." Then stop.

What this looks like in practice

Picture a six-agent team with 22 closings since September. Three clients have no phone on file, so they get email. The coordinator sends 8 messages on Day 4 and 7 on Day 5, each with the agent's own two sentences. By Day 8 a handful of reviews have arrived. She replies to each review the afternoon it appears and flags one critical review for the broker. Not a flood, but a few honest, recent reviews and replies that show how the team treats a conversation.

Check the profile before Day 4. Metricool's 2026 Social Media Study, which counted Google Business Profile among its ten platforms, found bookings rose 13% and direction requests increased 34% in 2025. People use the profile to act. Confirm the address, hours, categories and one recent photo.

How Urban Marketing Edge handles this

Our Google Business Profile work is included in the Agent Starter, Broker Growth and Team Marketing Department plans: profile cleanup, correct categories and service areas, brand-matched photos, monthly posts on the team plans, and a review request script with the three moments in a transaction when to use it. Your team replies using the templates included in the setup.

We do not write or solicit reviews on your behalf. A review has to come from your client, in their words. We keep the profile current, hand you the script and put the plan on the calendar. You can see what each plan includes on our plans page, and the free past client outreach prompt helps you write the personal line for each client.

Questions brokers ask

How soon after closing should I ask for a review?

Within the first few weeks, while the client still remembers the process. For fall closings, send it now. Wait about a week, then follow up once.

Can I give my clients a gift for leaving a review?

No. Google's help page says offering free or discounted goods or services in exchange for reviews is strictly prohibited. Give the closing gift as an unconditional thank-you and keep the review request separate.

Should I ask only the clients I know are happy?

No. Google's policy says businesses may not selectively solicit positive reviews. Build your list by closing date and send everyone the same message. If one closing involves an open complaint, the broker decides what happens and writes it down.

Should I reply to every Google review?

Yes, with a short, personal reply. Google's guidance says replying shows customers their feedback matters. Use the reviewer's name and one real detail. For a critical review, say what you will change and move the details offline.

Do I need a separate profile for each agent?

Not necessarily. The clean rule is one link per client, pointing to the profile that client would search for, so reviews build up in one place.

Book a 30-minute strategy call

Bring your last twenty closings to a call. We will look at your profile together, pick the one link each client should get, and map the two weeks around your holiday schedule. No pitch deck, no pressure.

Book a 30-minute strategy call and we will build the simplest version first. To see what a month with us looks like first, start with our plans.


Written by

Casey McClintic, founder of Urban Marketing Edge. Ten years of real estate marketing for brokerages, luxury teams and agents. About Casey

Next step

Ready for a brand that shows up every month?

30 minutes. We map the simplest plan for your content, themes and monthly cadence. No pitch deck.

Book a 30-minute strategy call
Book 30 minutes